29 Votes in Poll
Polls aren't a way to remove an admin. It would require a discussion on the wiki itself for visibility. It would need a community vote, but there isn't enough of an active community to speak of so there won't be enough participants.
The whole DCAU would include Superman & Batman Adventures, Adventures in the DC Universe, and much more. Much of it contradicts the shows, and some of which doesn't. We only cover the core in depth. Sorry if that doesn't include the two recent movies you happened to have seen.
It sure does contradict itself. That's why having a Canon or Not Canon section on pages is the only thing that's actually needed. If it contradicts animation, then it's Not Canon. Pretty simple. And as for Batman and Harley Quinn and Justice League VS Fatal Five, Bruce Timm has literally confirmed these to be canon within the DCAU so there's no reason they should be treated as any less on this wikia.
You just pick and choose what you personally consider canon to the universe. You don't like it? Not canon. Unfortunately whether you're into Harry Potter, Star Trek or Star Wars, every franchise has stuff that's not at the same standard as the rest of the stuff but that doesn't mean it doesn't exist in-world
"Bruce Timm has literally confirmed these to be canon within the DCAU"
Not that simple.
I mean...yes it is. The creators of a series are the final authority.
Bruce Timm has consistently said Beyond takes place "50 years after now, whenever now is" and asserted his dominance on that, despite the fact that Dini's ROTJ screenplay, WB's promotional material and an episode of TZP explicitly place it 40 years after the series premiere or close to. Would "the final authority" invalidate those?
Timm is one of the driving forces behind the DCAU. He is, however, not the sole driving force, nor its exclusive god. If anything, WB gets to decide. And as long as they hold off the boat, Timm's "I like to think so" is not sufficient.
I have no problem with it being canon for you. I have no problem with it being canon for me. There aren't that many continuity errors, apparently just all the bad guy cameos in the Bludhaven bar. But this is not simple, and not set in stone.
The DCAU is not a singular continuity. There are regular tie-in comics, retroactive comics, magazines, games (and "The Lost Episode"), Del Rey guidebooks, tons of Capstone books, a couple of shorts/pilot episodes, much of it doesn't actually contradict the core. And some does. And some contradicts the other. But that doesn't mean it's just pick and mix. Early on, even before I got here, the wiki decided to follow a "Memory Alpha" like approach of only covering the core series (and, for some reason, the webseries).
And just to reiterate, we don't "refuse to accept the DCAU as a whole". That is a dishonest spin grounded in your own biases that ignores reality. We acknowledge that there is no "whole" and do not recognize your definition of it as valid. Your position is no less arbitrary than ours.
Canon isn't dependent on constancy, so citing a contradiction has nothing to do with it.
You don't need the word of God to make it so. Abraham will do just fine. They work together. Really closely.
When you have a preponderance of evidence for, and nothing definitive against, then insisting it isn't is just plain old stubbornness.
If God and Abraham say something different on A, that's a valid reason to not take Abraham's word as gospel on B. No matter how much you like it. That's not stubbornness. That's not to say I can't be stubborn, no argument there.
This is something people need to accept and get over: your position is not as clear cut as you claim it is. As long as you don't, this discussion will not go anywhere and definitely not in your favor.
We cover the movies with pages; even if we deleted other non-DCAU projects we could probably keep those and treat them like our comics page. We did cover the movies in more detail, but it devolved into an edit war by people unable to accept the reality of vagueness and now the pages are bare.
@BitchesBrew Why he does his job and I have no complaints (He has blocked me twice in the past but he was just doing his job)
What do you think?